Manned Guarding Security V. CCTV | What’s The Best Option For Your South Wales Business?

Security guard looking at CCTV monitors in industrial unit Swansea South Wales

With the increase in global terrorism, the rise of sophisticated criminals, and the ever-growing costs of security breaches, the question of which is better – manned guarding or CCTV surveillance – is more relevant than ever.

While both have advantages and disadvantages, the answer is not always clear-cut. The right type of security service for your Swansea & South Wales business will depend on several factors, including a budget, the level of security risk, and the nature of your business.

In this article, we’ll take a closer look at manned guarding and CCTV surveillance, so you can decide which is best for your business. Let’s get started.

Local security guard RGM

Manned Security Guarding

Manned guarding is the use of security personnel to protect people and property. Security guards are trained to detect and respond to security risks and can provide a visible deterrent to crime. It is an effective way to protect high-value assets, such as cash, jewellery, and artwork.

Also, manned guarding services can protect event venues, such as festivals and concerts. It can also protect critical infrastructures, such as power plants and airports as well as government and local authority buildings, manufacturing units as well as education establishments.

The Upsides of Manned Guard Security

Manned security guards are a vital part of any security strategy and can provide a wide range of benefits, including:

  • Deterrence Factor: The potential intruders will be deterred by the presence of a human guard as they will be more likely to be caught.
  • Response Time: A human guard can respond quickly to any incidents on the premises. Also, the guards can raise the alarm to the police or other emergency services if required.
  • Flexibility: Manned guarding can be tailored to meet the specific security needs of premises. For example, the number of guards can be increased during peak times or special events.
  • Professionalism: Security guards are trained to deal with a wide range of security risks and can provide a high level of service.
  • Adaptability: A human guard can adapt to changing circumstances more easily than a CCTV system. For example, a guard can patrol a larger area if required.

The Downsides of Static Manned Guard Security

  • Cost: With all the benefits that manned security guards can provide, it’s no surprise they come at a cost. The price will depend on various factors, such as the type of premises to be protected and the level of security required.
  • Supervision Needed: Manned security guards must be supervised to ensure they carry out their duties effectively. This can be a time-consuming and costly exercise.

CCTV Surveillance Systems

An affordable, highly effective way of deterring crime, a CCTV surveillance system is a great security measure for any business or home. Capturing high-quality video footage, CCTV cameras can be used to monitor and record activity both inside and outside of your premises. From dome cameras to wireless systems, many different types of CCTV cameras work towards the same goal – keeping you and your property safe.

The Upsides To CCTV Surveilance

  • Monitoring Activity: By recording footage of activity, CCTV surveillance systems can be used to keep an eye on employees, customers, and visitors. This footage can also be used as evidence should a crime take place.
  • Adaptability: CCTV cameras can be used in various ways to suit the specific needs of your business or home. For example, they can monitor cash registers, entry and exit points, and high-value items.
  • Interactivity: With the addition of IP cameras, some CCTV surveillance systems can be made interactive. This means you can view footage and control the camera, zooming in and out as necessary. Also, warnings can be sent to your phone or email in real time if the camera detects movement outside of its normal parameters.
  • Low Maintenance Required: Most CCTV surveillance systems require very little maintenance once installed. This makes them an ideal security measure for busy businesses and homes.

The Downsides to CCTV Surveilance

Some business owners or homeowners might feel that a CCTV surveillance system is all they need to deter crime and protect their property. However, there are some limitations to consider before making your decision.

  • Hefty Upfront Costs: The initial upfront costs of purchasing and installing and CCTV surveillance can be expensive. 
  • Theft: While CCTV cameras can help to deter crime, they cannot prevent it from happening. If a thief is determined to break into your property, they will most likely find a way to do so.
  • Damage: CCTV cameras are physical objects that can be damaged or broken. If this happens, you will need to replace or repair the camera, which can be costly.
  • Range: The range of a CCTV camera is limited. You must install multiple cameras to cover all areas if you have a large property. This can increase the cost of your system.
  • Blind Spots: No matter how many cameras you have, there will always be blind spots that cannot be monitored. It’s important to consider this when planning your security system.
Security Guard on the telephone in front of 5 CCTV Security Monitors

Which Is Best For Your Business?

After going through the pros and cons of both manned guarding and CCTV, you must have a pretty good idea about which security system will be best for your business. However, if you are still not sure, then consider the following factors before making your decision:

  • Type Of Business: If you have a business that deals with high-value items, manned guarding is the best option. For instance, if you own a jewellery store, you need someone to always keep an eye on it. On the other hand, CCTV can be a better option if your business is not that high-value oriented.
  • Size Of Business: With a large business, keeping an eye on everything is impossible. CCTV can be very helpful in such a case as you can monitor different areas simultaneously. However, you can easily get away with a security guard if your business is small.
  • Budget: Manned security services are more expensive as compared to security cameras. CCTV is the way to go if you have a limited budget.
  • Location: The location of your business also plays a role in deciding which security system to choose. If your business is located in a high-crime area, it is better to opt for security officers. For businesses located in low-crime areas, CCTV can be a good option.


By weighing the pros and cons of each security measure, you can make an informed decision about which one is right for your business. Security guards may be the best option if you need a more comprehensive security solution. CCTV may be the way to go if you’re looking for a more affordable option. Ultimately, the decision is up to you.

No security system is perfect, but combining different security measures can create a layered approach that will give you the best chance of deterring crime and keeping your property and employees safe.

How Can RGM Security Help You?

RGM Security Ltd provide a comprehensive range of professional security guard services in Cardiff, Swansea and right across the South Wales area to both the public and private sector.

All our security guards are fully trained and SIA licensed giving you peace of mind you and your business are in the safest possible hands.

For more information on our company and the exceptionally high standard of services we offer please don’t hesitate to call us either on 01792 293249, or 02920 102464  or contact us here.

Colour graphic of PDF weakness guide checklist from RGM Security Ltd

Fill in your information below and we will email you a guide to checking weaknesses in your organisation